Techniques › Baking and pastry
Baking swaps: which substitutions work and which fail
Intermediate Baking and pastry
Which ingredient swaps are safe in baking and which ones change the chemistry so much that the recipe fails.
Written with AI help from the sources listed, and published by Cory. Spot a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it.
How do you do it?
- Works: for 1 cup buttermilk, stir 1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar into 1 cup milk and let it sit 5 to 10 minutes.
- Works: for 1 cup cake flour, use 1 cup all-purpose minus 2 tablespoons, plus 2 tablespoons cornstarch. For brown sugar, add 1 tablespoon molasses per cup of white sugar.
- Fails: baking soda and baking powder aren't interchangeable. Soda is about three to four times stronger and needs an acid.
- Risky: honey for sugar, oil for butter in creamed recipes, or more than about a quarter whole-wheat flour changes texture noticeably.
- Gluten-free flour works only as a blend made for one-to-one swapping; single flours fail.
Why does it work?
Baking is chemistry, and each ingredient does several jobs. Sugar tenderizes, holds moisture and helps aeration when creamed, so liquid honey changes all three. Solid butter traps air and makes flaky layers; oil can't. Leaveners need the right acid balance. Gluten from wheat builds structure, so other flours need gums or starches to replace it.
What are the common mistakes?
- Swapping baking powder for soda one-to-one — flat, metallic, soapy-tasting results.
- Swapping several ingredients at once — you can't tell what went wrong.
- Replacing eggs in a meringue or custard — eggs are the structure; nothing stands in.
Still stuck? Watch someone do it on YouTube.
Learn by cooking. In Pantry to Pan, technique words in your recipes' steps link straight
to guides like this one, right when you need them.
Try it free for 14 daysMore baking and pastry
- FoldingMixing something light (whipped cream, beaten egg whites) into something heavier without knocking the air out.Intermediate
- Creaming butter and sugarBeating soft butter with sugar until pale and fluffy — the start of most cakes and cookies.Beginner
- KneadingWorking dough by hand or machine until smooth and stretchy.Beginner
- Proofing (letting dough rise)Letting yeast dough rest and rise before baking.Beginner
- Cutting in butterWorking cold butter into flour until it's in small lumps — pie crust, biscuits, scones.Intermediate
- Blind bakingBaking a pie crust before it's filled.Intermediate